The Science of Brand Consistency: How Buyer Memories Build Brands

September 13, 2022

The Science of Brand Consistency: How Buyer Memories Build Brands

Mental Availability: The Long & the Short of it

Michael Murray

Sign up to get the latest industry trends, data stories, and creative inspiration direct to your inbox.

Today’s brand marketing should be focused on securing mental availability. This refers to increasing the likelihood that a brand will come easily to mind in a relevant buying situation. Building mental availability is one of the tenets of how brands grow (the other being physical availability, or how easy it is for people to buy the brand in relevant buying situations).

The science of brand consistency is, in many ways, the science of how the mind works. It deals with memories, behavioral science, and empirical laws of consumer purchasing behavior. It’s rooted in System 1 thinking, the fast, instinctive, and emotional way people tend to make decisions. Brand consistency plays a major role in building and maintaining memory structures. Specifically, it helps to refresh memories, which – studies have repeatedly shown – decay over time, thereby helping to increase the feeling, fame, and fluency of brands.

Diagram connecting brand perceptions, benefits and associations

How consumer memories shape brand growth:

The following principles come from the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute of Marketing Science. They can be found in Building Distinctive Brand Assets by Professor Jenni Romaniuk.

  • Most everyday experiences do not become long-term memories: marketers have to work hard to ensure the branded communication cuts through people’s attention filter for the brand and Asset to be noticed and then stored in our memories.
  • Anchoring is a key step for building brand linkage: for an Asset to become linked to the brand, it must be anchored to the brand name (i.e., co-presented with the brand name/logo a sufficient number of times to refresh the link and especially noticeable when the DBA is first formed).
  • Memories decay and are vulnerable to contamination: memories evolve over time, and inconsistencies creep into them. Brand consistency helps strengthen prior memories by ensuring each new exposure is consistent with the last, making it easier for the category buyer to identify the brand in any situation.
  • Memories are defined by the company they keep: people store and retrieve memories for specific reasons. In most categories, this is to satisfy a job-to-be-done, such as satiate thirst. This means that the more associations – the larger the brand’s network of memory associations – the more mental availability.
  • Brand consistency and freshness are key variables: to maintain and improve branded associations, marketers need to refresh them so they are fresher or more recent and relevant than competitor brands. Consistency plays a pivotal role as inconsistencies damage freshness and retrieval, a cost that is, according to Professor Romaniuk, “paid in the future (reduced) strength of the branding in buyer memory.”

What all of this means is, Professor Romaniuk writes, “the brand’s Distinctive Assets typically emerge from the effective decisions marketers make about where and how to place the brand name and the asset together.”

Time and reach play key roles in this process because it takes time for category buyers to link a brand with its potential DBAs. The more category buyers marketers can get to trigger their brands in any given market, the greater the number of potential buyers for their brands. This is why Fame is a key metric (more on that below).

Brand Consistency: The Long and the Short

For marketers familiar with The Long and the Short of It by Les Binet and Peter Field, mental availability is the long to persuasion’s short.

For those unfamiliar with The Long and the Short of It, the report advises marketers to balance long-term brand-building marketing strategies with short-term sales activation strategies. Balancing both will enable marketers to create more demand that can be captured with direct response campaigns (which in turn provide more cash for long-term brand-building campaigns). This is what it looks like:

Chart comparing short-term sales activation with long-term brand building
Source: Les Binet & Peter Field, "The Long & The Short of it"

Speaking about the importance of balancing long and short-term strategies, Mark Ritson writes in Marketing Week,

“Long-form, long-running and more traditional media – mass-targeted and more emotional – works to build the brand with little or no call to product action. Shorter, multiple campaigns target specific segments for immediate activation, often taking a more digital turn. The work is linked by distinctive brand assets, so that the codes and brand associations that are conjured up in the brand work are then immediately activated and utilised in all the short promotions.”
Table comparing long-term brand building and short-term activation
Source: Mark Ritson - Marketing Week

Brand consistency takes time to build. It is essential, as marketers build their marketing strategies, that they use Distinctive Brand Assets to link their different approaches and map each campaign to their brands. This helps create more efficient advertising, as well as more effective advertising. Put differently, sales can be improved through greater mental availability.

“Sales calls and advertising work better when there are existing memory structures in viewers’ heads – so long as the advertising works with these memory structures,” said Professor Byron Sharp. “Advertising falls on barren ground when it reaches buyers who aren’t near a firm’s sales points.”

The more (associated) memories of a brand they have, the more likely they are to choose that brand in buying situations. As Professor Romaniuk explains, many brands approach advertising the wrong way and skip steps by failing to account for these dynamics.

“A lot of advertising is geared to persuasion rather than building mental availability," said Professor Romaniuk. "Persuasion is about assuming you're in the room arguing your point, whereas mental availability is about getting into the room. And so that's the big challenge: most organisations are failing to get into the room, but they're spending all their money arguing as if they're already there.”

Before trying to persuade potential category buyers, a brand and its assets must first stand out and get noticed in the right way. Brand consistency is the long-term effectiveness play that unfolds thereafter, cementing distinction and growing familiarity in the minds of category buyers. Professor Romaniuk writes,

“The big, flashy, shiny things get all the attention, but much of an effective Distinctive Asset’s strategy is rooted in the quiet, behind-the-scenes discipline of persisting on a path of consistent, excellent execution.”

This is a multi-part, weekly series exploring — through data — how marketers can deliver brand consistency and some common pitfalls to watch out for.

Part one spotlights data on the value of brand consistency, part two explores the science of brand consistency, part three explores the value of Distinctive Brand Assets, part four unpacks how to develop brand consistency, part five highlights why brands are adopting Creative Quality, part six looks at brand alignment, part seven breaks down the importance of scale, part eight reveals how brands are managing scaling challenges, part nine looks at how brands are scaling their marketing efforts.

The next article in this brand consistency series explores the Value of Distinctive Brand Assets. Read to learn more about the challenges marketers face when deploying Distinctive Brand Assets.

→ See how the world's leading brands are using creative data to drive business impact:

Stories, ideas, and  practical insights from CreativeX

Loading the newsletter form...

Team member portrait
Join 3000+ subscribers!
City skyline at sunset above a dark body of water.